Zen – beyond happy & meaningful, Part 2

Caption: “See me, feel me, touch me, heal me” – lyric from Tommy (1975 Film) by The Who

So, well-being – beyond a feeling of happiness and a sense of meaning – is more than an end state. It’s something that remains dynamic, something contrary to complacency. It’s an ongoing state of engagement, of paying attention.

A key aspect of well-being is a perspective, a skillset which deals with the ongoing hard times in life without lapsing into despair. A balance.

This Big Think article addresses this ongoing dynamic, and why chasing happiness directly – as if seeking a magic fountain of joy – can be counterproductive.

The work of well-being (in a world of worries) is to “build a baseline of positivity that actually lasts.” And that is something which Zen addresses, amid the challenges of our attention age.

• Big Think > “3 experts explain how to escape the happiness paradox” by Robert Waldinger MD, Tal Ben-Shahar PhD, and Peter Baumann (Sept 2025) – What if the secret to a happier life wasn’t constant joy, but something far more balanced? [Video 2:57]

We created this video … to help people challenge their perceptions and expand their thinking. Often that growth can start with just a single unlikely question that makes you rethink your convictions and adjust your vantage point.

(from transcript)
TAL BEN-SHAHAR: There is a false understanding that a happy life means being happy all the time. No, it’s not. Learning to accept and even embrace painful emotions is an important part of a happy life.

ROBERT WALDINGER: The good life involves a practice of ongoing care for each other, for our relationships, care for ourselves, and it’s a process of continual change.

TAL BEN-SHAHAR: It’s a lifelong journey. So happiness is much more than pleasure. Happiness is whole being.

This second Big Think article is a long-form lecture (video 01:01:37), organized into 5 chapters. It expands on the article above.

• Big Think > “What 85 years of research says is the real key to happiness” with Robert Waldinger (the fourth director of the 85-year Harvard Study of Adult Development) – We never figure it out ultimately, and that that’s perfectly normal. And actually, it’s what makes life rich and interesting.

When we watch these thousands of lives play out over time, what we see is that the good life is an ongoing process, and it’s a process of continual change, which is different from what we all wish for, which is that we would finally get to a place where everything’s good and it’s gonna stay that way.

CHAPTER 1 The 85-year quest to understand happiness
CHAPTER 2 The relationship advantage
CHAPTER 3 Strengthening your connections
CHAPTER 4 Mindfulness, Zen & the good life [@ 29:13]
CHAPTER 5 What to do about loneliness

Chapter 2, The relationship advantage, discusses the essential question, “Do I have what I need?” A Goldilocks zone of connections. And positive emotion regulators.

Chapter 3 discusses social fitness and curated voices. “Paying attention really matters … [and] bringing curiosity to relationships that you might take for granted.”

“And each person can check in with themselves about that.” Which gets us to mindfulness and Zen (Chapter 4). And the “interconnectedness of everything.”

(A corresponding post will focus on mindfulness and Stoicism.)

(excepts)
Zen emphasizes community. It’s called Sangha, in the Buddhist language. And it’s really the idea that we practice learning about ourselves and each other by being in relationships with each other, both during meditation sessions and out there in the world. So, we practice with whatever comes up for us.

Well, the main explicit goal of zen is nothing. Zen is a practice. Now, the side effect of practice is waking up. Waking up really means understanding more deeply the truth of what it means to be alive, the truth, for example, that everything is constantly changing, including me, that even the things that look like they are fixed and stable are always in a process of continual change. That’s really helpful because often we try to fix things, we try to hold onto things and make them stay the same, and we suffer a lot when we do that.

It’s often said that the Buddha was teaching that you could get to a point where you never suffer anymore. Zen does not teach that. Zen does not teach that anybody finally arrives at a place where we don’t ever feel pain, where we don’t ever feel worry or unhappiness. Rather, what we can do is learn to be with what’s unsatisfactory in life, learn to be with unhappiness, even be with pain in a way that makes it more bearable, in a way that doesn’t layer on optional suffering.

But zen teaches that unsatisfactoriness is always there in life, and that we do have preferences that we’re never going to completely give up our preferences, but that what we can do is learn to clinging less tightly to our preferences.

In other words, to insist less that the world be a certain way. I mean, think about in relationships how much we try to insist that someone else be a certain way that we want them to be, and how much less we suffer if we let that go. And just assume that that person is allowed to show up in the world as they are, and we are allowed to show up in the world as we are.

So, this idea of relieving suffering is in zen. The idea of being able to face towards suffering, looking at it and living with it in a way that hurts less.

Buddhism talks about the idea of attachment. And it doesn’t mean attachment in the way we normally think of it, like just being connected to somebody or something. It’s really about holding on tightly to a fixed view of something.

So, I’m attached to the idea that there’s one true religion or one true political party, or one true anything.

Shunryu Suzuki was a zen master who had a saying that I love. He said, “In the beginner’s mind, there are many possibilities. In the expert’s mind, there are few.” And what he meant by that is when we can remain open to many possibilities rather than narrowing everything down and being so sure that we know what’s what, that we become open to surprise, open to new ways of experiencing ourselves and the world that make us suffer a great deal less than when we are so-called experts.

And the older I get and the more people call me an expert, the more aware I am of how little I know. Having a beginner’s mind really helps in relationships because it allows us to be curious.

What we teach in zen is … that nobody lives in a kind of unusual altered state all the time. [There’s always the laundry.]

So, although most of us, myself included, wish that there were a way to get enlightened and stay that way, to get to a place where it’s always blissful and we never suffer, I have never met a human being on this earth who gets to that place.

And zen teaching is that that’s not possible. That in fact, we move in and out of states of being more awakened or less awakened. That no matter how evolved you are as a spiritual practitioner, you’re gonna have times when you’re just all upset about stupid stuff, when you’re just deluded, as we say. And then you move back into periods where you see life more clearly.

That’s important for me because if you meet people who hold themselves out as an ultimately enlightened person, be very suspicious of that. Be very suspicious of anybody who claims to be a perfectly evolved, enlightened human being.

And so, the idea of pursuing enlightenment really is not pursuing a self-improvement project. It’s pursuing a way to be as compassionate as I can in each moment, to pursue enlightened activity in as many moments as I can string together in my life.

Striving for enlightenment is a self-improvement project. And what we talk about in my zen tradition is that we don’t want to embark on a self-improvement project. We want to strive for greater kindness and harmony in the world rather than being lost in the delusion of an isolated permanent self. And so, really what we wanna strive for is enlightened activity in the world.

Video transcript [protected page]

“What 85 years of research says is the real key to happiness”

Related articles

[See comments]

3 comments on “Zen – beyond happy & meaningful, Part 2

  1. Virtue social circles
    “What really makes someone a good person?”

    Psychologist and neuroscientist Sarah Schnitker studies how traits like patience, courage, and compassion are built through repeated practice in real-life situations. She’s found that virtues grow not from comfort, but from challenge.

    She shares how in one study, for example, people who fasted during Ramadan for spiritual reasons showed lasting increases in self-control weeks later. These moral habits take time and intention to build, but they not only improve our own well-being, they also help strengthen the communities we’re part of.

    • Big Think > “Is virtue worth pursuing? A psychologist explains” by Sarah Schnitker (August 2025) Video [6:24] – Self-help shortcuts (hacks) miss the mark.

    Key points (somewhat paraphrased)

    • Virtue is about moving farther along a trajectory toward being a better person.
    • We’re not ever going to really attain perfect virtue.
    • Virtue requires training, habits, a community.
    • It’s hard work – moving from the abstract (of wanting virtues) to actual habits.
    • Cultivating virtues requires practice in the situations that require them.
    • To build patience, you’re going to actually have to wait. To build courage, you will likely need to face threats. (And compassion, justness, kindness, …)
    • Seeking virtue for personal happiness or performance loses the moral component.
    • Pursuing virtue is not a self-improvement project – it’s about benefiting others, about the greater social, cultural good.

    Excerpts from transcript

    SARAH SCHNITKER: I think people often think of virtues as about the self, and am I happy and fulfilled? But that self starts to look kind of empty if it is not stretching outwards.

    Our data show very consistently that people who are virtuous have higher well-being. They have more positive emotions, fewer negative emotions, report greater satisfaction with life, greater meaning in life. And so what we hope to do is to help people train to become virtuous.

    … we find that people actually struggle more to practice that virtue when it’s just about the self versus the community and the relationality that’s necessary for virtue development.

  2. Overlapped success and happiness
    Does career / work success automatically ensure happiness? Do pay increases have large and long-lasting effects on job satisfaction?

    This article (video) explains that: “To get actual happiness from work, you need to seek two things, and really two things only. We call them earned success and service to others.”

    • Harvard Business Review > “The Success-Then-Happiness Fallacy” (8-12-2025) [Video 2:47] by Arthur C. Brooks, author of The Happiness Files: Insights on Work and Life – Chasing success has costs that can end up lowering happiness, as many a desiccated, lonely workaholic can tell you. Instead, start focusing on the less visible “happiness metrics” of your work.

    Summary

    Many professionals pursue success first, assuming happiness will follow. But research shows that this sequence is flawed: success alone rarely delivers lasting satisfaction. Instead, happiness is a strong predictor of success across work, relationships, and health. Leaders and employees alike benefit from reversing the order – investing in happiness to fuel performance.

    Excerpts from transcript

    One of the reasons I study happiness for a living is that I’m not naturally happy. No researcher worth his or her salt will claim that shortcuts exist, whether personally or professionally. Developing proper happiness hygiene requires serious work over time, which, in my view, is part of the adventure.

    The biggest mistake that people make about work and happiness is thinking that success and worldly terms is gonna bring happiness. And it’s not true. The worldly success from work has to do with money, and power, and the admiration of other people, and job titles, et cetera, et cetera. And a lot of people, mistakenly, think that those markers of success will bring happiness in its wake.

    I’ve been [doing] research for years as an economist on labor markets, and the characteristics of work, and it’s true that you need to make an income where you can support yourself and your family. But that doesn’t bring happiness. That just eliminates the sources of unhappiness.

    That’s why it’s so critically important that people who are bosses, people who are managers, that they help other people to earn their success, and they recognize the value that people are creating.

    That’s why meritocracy [and mentoring] is so critically important for people to get actual joy from their work.

    The second is service to other people. You have to feel like your job matters to others, and you’re lightening somebody else’s load. Then you’ll go to work with joy.

    In my own research, I have found that the most meaningful jobs – which bring the most happiness – tend to be those that are service-oriented.

    Understanding how your job serves others isn’t easy for everyone. In the for-profit world, up to 77% of corporate employees feel as though they are a cog in a machine. It is your responsibility as a leader to show employees how their jobs serve others.

    Here are two “Happiness Exercises” – one for your own happiness and another to help your team’s well-being – that you can begin and complete in a week.

  3. eye of imperfection

    In the context of seeking success & happiness, here’s another perspective on friction, as an inevitable aspect of life. In this case, a perfectionist mindset vs. “getting real” about:

    * Flaws – you’re continually “bugged” because not everything (or every experience) is perfectly to your liking or expectation.

    * Shelf life – your wonderful (or at least good enough) sweet-spot (or spotless space, eh) of familiarity and meaning is challenged by change – doesn’t last forever.

    * Summiting – your quest for a final state (or place) of ascendency (or validation) is a letdown – an unsatisfying “false peak.”

    The wellness of the world within and without is an ongoing journey – a process, not a perfected place (or perfected recipe). Not a permanent state. Not a completed trek.

    This article includes some tips on practicing Wabi-Sabi [1] in daily life.

    • Psychology Today > Why Wabi-Sabi Is the Best Philosophy of Life by Mark Travers Ph.D., reviewed by Lybi Ma (December 24, 2025) – A Japanese philosophy that helps us see life’s imperfections as irreplaceable.

    Summary points (quoted)

    1. Wabi-Sabi Reduces Perfectionism and Anxiety
    2. Wabi-Sabi Encourages Emotional Resilience
    3. Wabi-Sabi Doesn’t Equate Beauty with Perfection

    Incorporating a practice of wabi-sabi into one’s life entails, through repeated reinforcement, treating cracks, wear-and-tear, and the passage of time not as flaws, but as the core of what makes life beautiful and meaningful.

    The essence of this philosophy lies in acceptance — holding ambiguity, change, and aging with openness rather than resistance.

    In the simplest terms, the philosophy gently nudges us to lean into change, instead of constantly trying to fight it. In addition to this, it also asks us to honor the scars we may have endured in the process, rather than trying to erase or reduce them.

    According to both, things that endure, change, or age well often carry deeper significance than those that stay flawless.

    Psychologically, when we see ourselves and our lives as works in progress, we make room for patience, humility, and long-term growth.

    Notes

    [1] Wiki > Wabi-sabi

    Wabi-sabi has roots in Zen Buddhism. It began to shape Japanese culture when the Zen priest Murata Juko (1423–1502) modified the tea ceremony. He introduced simple, rough wooden and clay instruments in place of the gold, jade, and porcelain then popular in the Chinese-style tea service. About one hundred years later, the tea master Sen no Rikyu (1522 to 21 April 1591) introduced wabi-sabi to the nobility through his design of the teahouse. “He constructed a teahouse with a door so low that even the emperor would have to bow in order to enter, reminding everyone of the importance of humility before tradition, mystery, and spirit.

    In traditional Japanese aesthetics, wabi-sabi centers on the acceptance of transience and imperfection. It is often described as the appreciation of beauty that is “imperfect, impermanent, and incomplete”.

    Wabi-sabi combines two interrelated concepts: wabi and sabi. According to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, wabi may be translated as “subdued, austere beauty”, and sabi as “rustic patina”. Wabi-sabi derives from the Buddhist teaching of the three marks of existence, which include impermanence, suffering, and emptiness or absence of self-nature.

    According to Richard Powell, “Wabi-sabi nurtures all that is authentic by acknowledging three simple realities: nothing lasts, nothing is finished, and nothing is perfect.”

Comments are closed.